The Tor Network

Topics

  • What is Tor?
  • Types of relays
  • Technical setup
  • More about relays
  • Relay diversity
  • Getting help

What is Tor?

  • Tor is free software and an open network.
  • Mitigates against tracking, surveillance and censorship.
  • Run by a US non-profit and volunteers from all over the world.
  • It's Tor, not TOR.

The Tor network

  • An open network that everyone can be a part of.
  • The network is composed of different types of servers run by volunteers around the world.
  • Your server will relay the Tor traffic to another server on the Internet.
  • Before entering the network, your server will automatically go through the relay lifecycle.

Why run a Tor relay?

By running a Tor relay, you can help make the Tor network:

  • faster (and therefore more usable)
  • more robust against attacks
  • more stable in case of outages
  • safer for users (spying on more relays is harder than on a few)

Types of Relays

Guard/middle (aka non-exit) relay

  • A guard is the first relay in the chain of 3 relays building a Tor circuit.
  • A middle relay is neither a guard nor an exit, but acts as the second hop between them.
  • To become a guard, a middle relay has to be stable and fast (at least 2MByte/s); otherwise, it will remain a middle relay.

Exit relay

  • The exit relay is the final relay in a Tor circuit, and sends the traffic to its destination.
  • That is why exit relays have the most significant legal exposure and liability of all relays.
  • Before running an exit relay, talk with your local digital rights organization.
  • You should not run a Tor exit relay from your home.

Bridge

  • A bridge is a node in the network that is not listed in the public Tor directory, making it harder for ISPs and governments to block it.
  • Bridges are relatively easy, low-risk, and low bandwidth Tor relays to operate.
  • And there's another special kind of bridge: Pluggable transports. These hide your Tor traffic by adding a layer of obfuscation.

The lifecycle of a new relay

Non-exit relays go through a lifecycle of four phases (defined in days):

  • Days 0-3: the unmeasured phase.
  • Days 3-8: network authorities start the remote measurement phase (the ramp-up guard phase).
  • Days 8-68: guard phase (where load counter intuitively drops and then rises higher).

The lifecycle of a new relay

Relay requirements

Before we start

  • Never run a relay without the consent of the network administrator or machine owner. Read the Terms of Service (ToS) first, so you don’t risk losing money.
  • Choose which type of relay you will host. A non-exit relay is an easy way to start helping the network.
  • Read the documentation: https://sgapqzbrdr.oedi.net/relay

Bandwidth requirements

  • It’s recommended to have at least 16 Mbit/s (Mbps) upload and download bandwidth available for Tor. More is better.
  • The minimum requirements for a relay are 10 Mbit/s (Mbps).
  • If you have less than 10 Mbit/s but at least 1 Mbit/s, we recommend running a bridge with obfs4 support.

Monthly outbound traffic

  • Relays must use at least 100 GByte of outbound/incoming traffic per month.
  • If you have a metered plan, you might want to configure Tor to use only a given amount of bandwidth or monthly traffic.
  • More (>2 TB/month) is better and recommended.

Public IPv4 address

  • Every relay needs a public IPv4 address - either directly on the host (preferred) or via NAT and port forwarding.
  • The IPv4 address is not required to be static, but static IP addresses are preferred.
  • Your IPv4 address should remain unchanged for at least 3 hours (network consensus).
  • You can only run two Tor relays per public IPv4.

Other requirements

  • Memory: A <40 Mbit/s non-exit relay should have at least 512 MB of RAM available.
  • Disk storage: Tor does not need much disk storage. A typical Tor relay needs less than 200 MB.

Other requirements

  • Any modern CPU should be fine.
  • Uptime: Ideally, the relay runs on a server which runs 24/7.

Choosing your relay hosting

  • The Tor community team maintains GoodBadISPs – a list about the experience of running relays: https://sgapqzbrdr.oedi.net/relay/community-resources/good-bad-isps/
  • Some providers only allow non-exit relays, so check the GoodBadISPs list before buying a service.
  • Running a relay can cost anywhere between a few bucks to hundreds per month.

Technical setup

Non-exit relay - Debian/Ubuntu

  • Enable the Tor Project package repository
  • Install the tor package
$ apt update && apt install tor

Non-exit relay - Debian/Ubuntu

  • Add relay configuration to the /etc/tor/torrc file:
    Nickname myNiceRelay
ExitRelay 0
SocksPort 0
ORPort 9001
ContactInfo tor-operator@your-emailaddress-domain
Log notice syslog

Non-exit relay - Debian/Ubuntu

  • Restart the tor daemon:
$ systemctl restart tor@default

Non-exit relay - FreeBSD

  • Install the tor package
pkg install tor ca_root_nss

Non-exit relay - FreeBSD

  • Edit the configuration file /usr/local/etc/tor/torrc
Nickname myNiceRelay
ORPort 9001
ExitRelay 0
SocksPort 0
ContactInfo tor-operator@your-emailaddress-domain
Log notice syslog

Non-exit relay - FreeBSD

  • Ensure that the random_id sysctl setting is enabled:
echo "net.inet.ip.random_id=1" >> /etc/sysctl.conf
sysctl net.inet.ip.random_id=1

Non-exit relay - FreeBSD

  • Start the tor daemon and make sure it starts at boot:
sysrc tor_enable=YES
service tor start

Non-exit relay - FreeBSD

Verify that your relay works

After restarting the service, verify that the log file contains the following entry:

Self-testing indicates your ORPort is
reachable from the outside.
Excellent.
Publishing server descriptor.

About 3 hours after you started your relay, it should appear on Metrics portal in Relay Search.

More about relays

Technical tips

  • Enable automatic software updates.
  • Backup your Tor Identity Keys.
  • It's possible to limit bandwidth usage (and traffic). Check the parameters, for example, AccountingMax, AccountingRule, AccountingStart.
  • If you run more than one Tor relay, you need to set the MyFamily parameter.

Orchestrating

Metrics

  • Metrics portal: https://metrics.torproject.org
  • You can search for how many relays are in the network, how many are exits, etc.
  • In 2021 there are ~6,600 public relays and ~1,500 bridges.
  • Check: how many relays are in your country? Who runs these relays? How diverse are they?

Network diversity

Monoculture

  • A single kernel vulnerability in GNU/Linux impacting all Tor relays could be devastating.
  • Diversity of Operating System (OS): ~90% of relays are Linux.

Monoculture

  • Diversity of Autonomous Systems (AS).
  • Try to avoid the following hosters: OVH SAS (AS16276), Online S.a.s. (AS12876), Hetzner Online GmbH (AS24940), DigitalOcean, LLC (AS14061).

The TorBSD Diversity Project

  • The Tor BSD Diversity Project (TDP) is an initiative seeking to extend the use of BSD Unix operating systems in the network.
  • Goals: increase the number of Tor relays running BSDs; Engage the BSD community about Tor anonymity; Port Tor related programs to BSD operating systems.

More about exit relays

Legal information

  • Many countries have regulations that exclude internet service providers from liability.
  • It's a good idea to consult with a lawyer or your local digital rights organization.
  • Under most circumstances, you will be able to handle legal matters by having an abuse response letter.

Legal resources

Tips for running an exit relay

  • Get a separate IP for the relay, and don’t use it for other services.
  • Set up a Tor Exit Notice, so if someone checks your exit IP they'll know that it’s a Tor Exit.
  • If you receive excessive complaints, consider running a Reduced Exit Policy.
  • For more tips: https://vbdvexcmqi.oedi.net/tips-running-exit-node

Running relays with others

Running a relay with others

Relays associations

  • It's often advised to create some type of non-profit organization. This is useful for having a bank account and shared ownership.
  • The most important thing is to have a group of people (3-5 suggested to start) interested in helping.

Running a relay with universities

  • Universities are typically home to a reliable, robust, and well-equipped network.
  • Many computer science departments and university libraries run relays: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Universität Stuttgart, the University of Waterloo.

Running a relay with universities

At your company or organization

  • If you work at a Tor-friendly company or organization, that's another ideal place to run a relay.
  • Companies like Brass Horn Communications, Quintex Alliance Consulting, and many others run relays.
  • And organizations like Digital Courage, Access Now, Derechos Digitales, Calyx Institute, and Lebanon Libraries in New Hampshire.

Bad relays

What is a bad relay?

  • A bad relay is one that either doesn't work properly or tampers with our users' connections. That can be either through maliciousness or misconfiguration.

What is a bad relay?

  • For example: tampering with exit traffic in any way (including dropping accepted connections). Or, running HSDirs that harvest and probe .onion addresses

Reporting a bad relay

  • The "Bad relays" private working group at the Tor Project work to detect misconfigured, malicious, or suspicious relays.
  • Users can report bad relays by sending an email to bad-relays@lists.torproject.org with the relay’s IP address or fingerprint, what kind of behavior you see, and any additional information needed to reproduce the issue.

What happens to bad relays?

  • After a relay is reported and behavior has been verified, the Tor Project will attempt to contact the relay operator.
  • The relay will be flagged to prevent it from being used (BadExit, Invalid, Reject).
  • The working group actively looks for bad relays using open source tools like exitmap, sysbilhunter.

How do I get help running a Tor relay?

Getting help

Thank you!

torproject.org